Post published on December 1, 2022 by vspiceroute

Last post modified on August 14, 2023 by vspiceroute

Aloo Toasty or a Potato Sandwich is a simple sandwich with savory spicy potato filling. It is comfort food especially when you are craving for hot food during the winter months. I love to use the Amul Butter and Amul Cheese as it brings it one step closer to Bombay Sandwich. The sandwich chutney adds a good kick to this Toastie. The Aloo Stuffing is a basic stuffing that can be modified as per your taste. I also use the same Potato stuffing in Aloo Parathas. 


Aloo Toastie | Potato Sandwich

Aloo Sandwich or Potato Toastie reminds me of a sandwich place that was right across my school in India. It reminds me of the Sandwich shop right outside my school in India . Those days they used Sandwich Maker with handle. They toasted the sandwich on the Indian Coal grill. The crunchy outer edges of bread and hot filling would taste absolutely delicious. When I made this Sandwich it tasted very close to what I had when I was growing up. Checkout the quick and easy recipe below.
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 10 minutes
Course Breakfast, Brunch, lunch, sandwich, school lunchbox
Cuisine Indian Street Food
Servings 3 sandwiches


Potato Filling

  • 4 medium sized Potatoes Boiled and Peeled
  • 2 tsp green chili and ginger paste
  • 1/2 cup chopped cilantro
  • Salt as needed
  • 2 tsp raw mango powder


  • 2 cups Potato Filling
  • 6 slices of Bread
  • 3 tablespoon Sandwich chutney
  • 2 tsp chaat/ sandwich masala
  • 3 cubes of Amul Cheese
  • Salt as needed
  • 4 tablespoon Amul butter


  • Make the Potato Filling ahead of time by combining all the ingredients
  • Apply Amul Butter on the slices of bread
  • Apply chutney on the same side you applied butter on the bread
  • Layer 1/4th -1/2 cup of Potato Filling on the bread
  • Sprinkle chaat masala
  • Shred 1/2 cube of Amul Cheese on the potato filling
  • Seal the sandwich with another slice bread that has chutney and butter and face it towards the potato and cheese filling
  • Apply butter on the outer part of the bread before toasting it
  • You can toast it in a toasty maker or use a sandwich grill or a flat nonstick pan
  • Once the Sandwich is toasted on both sides, serve it hot with additional shredded Amul Cheese on top
  • Serve it along with Ketchup and Chutney
Keyword aloo sandwich, aloo toastie, alu sandwich, bateta ni sandwich, Bombay Grill Sandwich, easy potato sandwich, grill sandwich, indian grill sandwich, jalapeno toastie, Mumbai Sandwich, potato sandwich, potato toastie, potato toasty

Checkout my Youtube channel here